Dancing With the Stars fans erupted on social media. They were upset after Scott Hoying and Rylee Arnold were eliminated during the show’s “Wicked Night.” The couple’s exit shocked viewers and ignited a wave of anger online.
The ABC dance competition featured a night full of emotional performances. These were inspired by the musical Wicked. They were also inspired by the upcoming film Wicked: For Good. Fans expected big scores and surprising moves. Many stars impressed the judges and even earned the season’s first perfect 10s.
Scott Hoying, the Pentatonix singer, and his professional partner Rylee Arnold delivered a heartfelt performance. They danced to “The Wizard and I” from Wicked. The judges gave them a total of 28 out of 40 points. Combined with fan votes from Dedication Night and Wicked Night, it was not enough to keep them in the competition.
Fans Question the Results
Viewers could not believe Scott and Rylee went home. Many felt the elimination was unfair. They argued that other contestants who scored lower or struggled more remained in the competition.
Social media exploded with outrage. One fan wrote on X, “I’m absolutely heartbroken! Scott Hoying got eliminated! This elimination is homophobic! He didn’t deserve to go home! Andy Richter should have been eliminated! I’m shocked Dylan Efron was in the bottom three! I’m over it with the shocking eliminations! I’m furious!”
Another said, “Justice for Scott and Rylee bc how did they get eliminated over Andy.”
A third tweeted, “I mean no disrespect but WTF!” and added the hashtag #ScottAndRileyGotRobbed.
Many fans accused the judges of favoritism. Andy Richter, who consistently scored low, stayed while Scott and Rylee were sent home.
Couples in Jeopardy
Before the elimination, the judges called seven couples safe. That left three pairs in jeopardy:
- Scott Hoying and Rylee Arnold
- Andy Richter and Emma Slater
- Dylan Efron and Daniella Karagach
The tension rose as fans watched live. In the end, Scott and Rylee were sent home.
Scott and Rylee Speak Out
Scott took a moment to thank the show and fans. He said, “It’s meant everything. I’m so incredibly grateful for this.” He praised Rylee, calling her his favorite partner and saying, “I had so much fun. I learned so much.”
Rylee shared her feelings too. “Scott is such a kind soul, and dancing with him has been an incredible journey,” she said. Their bond was visible every week, making their elimination even harder for viewers to accept.
Social Media Backlash
Fans did not hold back. They flooded social platforms with messages demanding justice. Many questioned the voting system and how the judges scored performances. Some argued the elimination damaged the show’s credibility.
Key Moments That Shocked Fans
- Scott and Rylee’s contemporary dance received high praise
- Judges scored them 28 out of 40
- Fans believed Andy Richter should have been eliminated
- Dylan Efron also surprised viewers by landing in the bottom three
“The shocking eliminations make me furious,” one viewer wrote. “Scott and Rylee deserved to stay more than anyone.”
What Fans Want
Many viewers demanded changes to the voting system. They want transparency in scoring and more influence from fan votes. Some hope DWTS producers reconsider how eliminations happen.
Fans also expressed hope for Scott and Rylee’s return in future seasons or special performances. Their journey created a lasting impression.
The Legacy of Scott and Rylee
Despite leaving the competition, Scott and Rylee remain fan favorites. Their performances, connection, and professionalism earned admiration across the board. Fans continue to celebrate their talent and dedication.
DWTS Continues
As the season moves forward, fans will watch closely. They want fair competition and better representation of consistent talent. Scott and Rylee’s elimination has left a mark on the show, and viewers won’t forget.
Quotes from Fans
- “I’m shocked Dylan Efron was in the bottom three!”
- “Justice for Scott and Rylee. How did they get eliminated over Andy?”
- “This elimination is homophobic! Scott didn’t deserve to go home!”
Scott Hoying and Rylee Arnold’s elimination sparked one of the most heated fan reactions in Dancing With the Stars history. The duo’s talent, chemistry, and charm will not be forgotten. Fans will continue to voice their opinions and hope for justice in future competitions.
